1Idlewild
9.6 Exceptional rated by 55 guests
- Free parking
Best for self-catering stays
Runswick Bay
There are 32 holiday cottages in Runswick Bay. 23 of them take dogs, 29 list parking and 1 have a hot tub. Most are self-catering, so the nearest shop matters more than the nearest restaurant.
The Honest Rank
Ranked by guest reviews, not commission. How we rank places
19.6 Exceptional rated by 55 guests
Best for self-catering stays
29.4 Superb rated by 48 guests
Best for travelling with a dog and self-catering stays
39.3 Superb rated by 11 guests
Best for families and self-catering stays
There are only five top-rated places here, so the list also shows places with fewer guest reviews. They are marked by their review count.
| Place | Type | Guest score | Dogs allowed | Parking | Hot tub | Book |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Idlewild | Cottage | 9.6 (55) | No | Yes | No | Check |
Coach House Cottage | Cottage | 9.4 (48) | Yes | Yes | No | Check |
Host & Stay - Puffins Rest | Cottage | 9.3 (11) | No | Yes | No | Check |
Host & Stay - Salt & Seaweed | Cottage | 9.0 (35) | Yes | Yes | No | Check |
Tulip Cottage Hinderwell Whitby Staithes Pet Friendly - Genius | Cottage | 8.6 (51) | Yes | Yes | No | Check |
Evergreen House | Cottage | 9.8 (5) | Yes | Yes | No | Check |
Stunning Lodge at Runswick Bay - Dog Friendly | Cottage | 9.6 (6) | Yes | Yes | No | Check |
Ferndene Cottage | Cottage | 9.4 (5) | Yes | No | No | Check |
Pebble Cottage | Cottage | 9.5 (4) | Yes | Yes | No | Check |
Cresta Bungalow | Cottage | 10.0 (2) | Yes | Yes | No | Check |
Lobster Hollow - Luxury sea view retreat | Cottage | 10.0 (2) | Yes | Yes | No | Check |
St Hilda's Cottage | Cottage | 10.0 (2) | Yes | Yes | Yes | Check |
We may earn a commission if you book through our links. It never affects where a place ranks. Affiliate disclosure
Of the 32 holiday cottages here, 5 are top-rated by guests and those average 9.2 out of 10. By type, they are mostly holiday cottages (32).
By address, the most are in Hinderwell (23) and Runswick (9).
For comparison, Staithes has 67, Sleights & Esk Valley has 71 and Whitby has 1,014. Those pages are linked below.
Most holiday cottages are self-catering and many ask for a minimum stay in summer. Check the arrival day as well as the dates.

67 holiday cottages, about 2 miles away

71 holiday cottages, about 6 miles away

1,014 holiday cottages, about 7 miles away

2,695 places

8,691 places
We count 32 holiday cottages in Runswick Bay, and 5 of them are top-rated by guests. They are mostly holiday cottages (32). The table on this page compares the 12 with the strongest guest scores side by side.
Idlewild ranks first on guest reviews: a holiday cottage rated 9.6 by 55 guests. The ranking weighs each score by the number of reviews, so places with only a handful of reviews cannot jump to the top.
23 of the 32 places here list dogs as allowed. Fees, size limits and which rooms are available with a dog differ per place, so confirm them with the property before you book.
29 of the 32 places list parking, and 13 say it is free. Listed parking can be on site or a public car park close by, so ask how it works if you arrive late.
Details checked: September 2026. Always confirm dog fees, parking and access with the property before booking.