
Five Gables
9.5 Exceptional rated by 153 guests
- Dogs welcome
- Free parking
3 miles from Sheffield centre
Best for travelling with a dog
South Yorkshire
Sheffield has 626 places to stay: 283 holiday cottages, 242 apartments and 47 rooms and small guesthouses. 171 of them have consistently strong guest scores, averaging 9.1 out of 10. 393 list free parking, which matters more here than the guest score of the 20th place on the list.
The highest-ranked place of each main type, on guest reviews.
Top-rated hotel

9.5 Exceptional rated by 153 guests
3 miles from Sheffield centre
Best for travelling with a dog
Top-rated cottage or apartment

9.7 Exceptional rated by 71 guests
9.5 miles from Sheffield centre
Best for travelling with a dog and families
Top-rated B&B or pub with rooms

9.5 Exceptional rated by 50 guests
8 miles from Sheffield centre
Best for families

496 places to stay with parking

277 places nearby

242 apartments

183 central places to stay

77 budget-friendly places to stay

72 places near the station

67 high-end places to stay
The 20 places with the strongest guest scores in Sheffield itself (within about 2 miles of the centre), with the most-reviewed first when scores tie. Filter by what you need.
The Honest Rank
Ranked by guest reviews, not commission. How we rank places
20 of 20 shown
19.8 Exceptional rated by 40 guests
About a 10-minute walk from Sheffield centre
Best for arriving by train
29.7 Exceptional rated by 42 guests
A 5-minute walk from Sheffield centre
Best for arriving by train and self-catering stays
39.5 Exceptional rated by 283 guests
About a 20-minute walk from Sheffield centre
Best for arriving by train and self-catering stays
49.7 Exceptional rated by 32 guests
A 5-minute walk from Sheffield centre
Best for driving in and walking everywhere
59.5 Exceptional rated by 72 guests
About a 15-minute walk from Sheffield centre
Best for families and driving in and walking everywhere
69.5 Exceptional rated by 42 guests
1.5 miles from Sheffield centre
Best for travelling with a dog and families
79.4 Superb rated by 76 guests
A 5-minute walk from Sheffield centre
Best for arriving by train and families
89.5 Exceptional rated by 35 guests
A 5-minute walk from Sheffield centre
Best for arriving by train
99.4 Superb rated by 62 guests
About 25 to 30 minutes on foot from Sheffield centre
Best for arriving by train
109.4 Superb rated by 55 guests
About a 15-minute walk from Sheffield centre
Best for families and driving in and walking everywhere
119.3 Superb rated by 153 guests
About a 15-minute walk from Sheffield centre
129.3 Superb rated by 108 guests
About 25 to 30 minutes on foot from Sheffield centre
139.3 Superb rated by 98 guests
About a 15-minute walk from Sheffield centre
Best for families
149.6 Exceptional rated by 19 guests
About 25 to 30 minutes on foot from Sheffield centre
Best for travelling with a dog and families
159.4 Superb rated by 34 guests
About a 10-minute walk from Sheffield centre
Best for arriving by train and families
169.4 Superb rated by 33 guests
1.5 miles from Sheffield centre
Best for couples
179.2 Superb rated by 346 guests
About 25 to 30 minutes on foot from Sheffield centre
Best for families
189.4 Superb rated by 31 guests
About a 20-minute walk from Sheffield centre
Best for arriving by train
199.4 Superb rated by 26 guests
About 25 to 30 minutes on foot from Sheffield centre
209.3 Superb rated by 38 guests
A 5-minute walk from Sheffield centre
Best for arriving by train
We may earn a commission if you book through our links. It never affects where a place ranks. Affiliate disclosure
219 of the places counted for Sheffield are more than 2 miles from the centre. The top-rated of them, for when a car and a quieter night matter more than walking to dinner:

9.7 Exceptional rated by 125 guests
6.5 miles from Sheffield centre
Best for travelling with a dog and couples

9.7 Exceptional rated by 71 guests
9.5 miles from Sheffield centre
Best for travelling with a dog and families

9.7 Exceptional rated by 65 guests
3.5 miles from Sheffield centre
Best for travelling with a dog

9.7 Exceptional rated by 63 guests
5 miles from Sheffield centre
Best for travelling with a dog and families

9.6 Exceptional rated by 86 guests
8.5 miles from Sheffield centre
Best for families and self-catering stays

9.5 Exceptional rated by 153 guests
3 miles from Sheffield centre
Best for travelling with a dog
| Type | Places | Top-rated | Average guest score of top-rated | Dogs allowed | Parking | Hot tub | Self-catering |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hotels | 43 | 14 | 8.8 | 42% | 81% | 0% | 2% |
| Holiday cottages | 283 | 66 | 9.1 | 36% | 88% | 2% | 78% |
| Apartments | 242 | 69 | 9.1 | 21% | 73% | 2% | 73% |
| Rooms and small guesthouses | 47 | 16 | 9.1 | 13% | 51% | 4% | 2% |
Hotels suit a short stay and a late arrival. Sheffield has 43, 14 of them top-rated by guests. 9 of them are within about a 10-minute walk of the city centre. 24 list a restaurant, so dinner does not have to mean a taxi.
B&Bs, guesthouses and pubs with rooms number 7 here, and 3 of them list breakfast as available. They tend to be smaller, which shows in the guest scores: the 4 top-rated ones average 9.0. Parking is listed at 100%.
Cottages and apartments are the choice for three nights or more, or for a family: there are 525, 76% list a kitchen and 29% take dogs. You trade daily housekeeping for space and your own front door.
96 places are within about a 10-minute walk of the city centre of Sheffield, and 216 within about 20 minutes. The other 410 are further out, which usually means a car, a bus or a taxi for the evening.
By address, this is where the 626 places sit:
| Address locality | Places | Top-rated | Mostly | Dogs allowed | Typical distance to centre |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sheffield | 424 | 127 | Apartments | 25% | 25 min walk |
| Midland | 22 | 1 | Apartments | 27% | 10 min walk |
| Nether Edge | 16 | 1 | Holiday cottages | 38% | 2 miles |
| Walkley | 14 | 2 | Holiday cottages | 36% | 1.5 miles |
| Heeley | 13 | 2 | Holiday cottages | 38% | 1.5 miles |
| Victoria | 13 | 4 | Holiday cottages | 46% | 25 min walk |
| Neepsend | 10 | 2 | Holiday cottages | 40% | 30 min walk |
| Manor | 9 | 0 | Holiday cottages | 22% | 2.5 miles |
| Hillsborough | 7 | 5 | Apartments | 29% | 2.5 miles |
| Longley | 7 | 1 | Holiday cottages | 29% | 2.5 miles |
Parking. 496 of the 626 places list parking and 393 say it is free. If you are staying centrally, check whether the space is on site or a public car park before you arrive.
By train. 23 places are within about a 10-minute walk of Sheffield station and 125 within about 15 minutes. Walking times are estimates from the map, so allow extra time with luggage.
With a dog. 178 places take dogs (28%). The dog-friendly places are mostly holiday cottages (102) and apartments (51). Fees and limits differ, so confirm them with the property.
Worth filtering for. 20 list EV charging on site and 40 list facilities for disabled guests. Use the filters above the ranked list to see only those.
There are 626 places to stay in Sheffield in our comparison: 283 holiday cottages, 242 apartments and 47 rooms and small guesthouses. 171 of them have consistently strong guest scores, and those average 9.1 out of 10. The list on this page ranks them on guest reviews, not on commission.
On guest reviews, Stylish 3 bedroom apartment in historic city centre building ranks first: a apartment rated 9.8 by 40 guests. We weigh each score by how many guests have reviewed a place, so a single perfect review does not put anything at the top of the list.
Yes. 178 places in Sheffield list dogs as allowed, 28% of everything here, including 102 holiday cottages and 51 apartments. Dog fees and size limits differ per place, so check them with the property before you book.
496 of the 626 places in Sheffield list parking (79%), and 393 of them say it is free. Parking listed by a property can mean a private space or a public car park nearby, so ask when you book.
125 places are within about a 15-minute walk of Sheffield station, and 23 within about 10 minutes. Walking times are estimates from the map position, so check the route before you book if you have heavy luggage.
14 places in Sheffield list a hot tub, mostly 7 holiday cottages and 5 apartments. The listing does not always say whether the hot tub is private or shared, so check that with the property if it matters to you.
We may earn a commission if you book through our links. It never affects where a place ranks. Affiliate disclosure
Details checked: September 2026. Always confirm dog fees, parking and access with the property before booking.